A critical review of ‘A New Birth of Freedom: Lincoln and the Coming of the Civil War by Harry V. Jaffa

Type :

Book review

Pages :

5 pages

Format :

.doc

Published date :

06/03/2008

Category :

Philosophy & literature

Sub category :

Literature

Oboulo.com selection criteria

$ 10.95 Add to cart

Summary :

With the realization that Jaffa spends so much of he text focusing on Lincoln as a scholar, this investigation seeks to provide a clear understanding of Lincoln in this light.
Jaffa goes on to argue that Lincoln's interpretation of the Declaration of Independence is what served as the basis for him to support the abolition of slavery.
To illustrate this point one only needs to consider Francis Fisher Browne and John Y. Simon's recent biography which chronicles the everyday life of Abraham Lincoln.
Other writers examining Lincoln's life also appear to be quite preoccupied with Lincoln's ability to fit into his surroundings.
Neely maintains that Lincoln typically became rigid and inflexible in his attitudes and opinions, preferring to rely on to the strict interpretations provided by the Constitution.Although this may provide for provocative read material it does not appear to provide a fair and accurate picture of this historical figure.
In the end, Jaffa's work provides a strong historical analysis of how Lincoln was able to effectively serve as president of the United States.

Abstract

A new birth of freedom: lincoln and the coming of the civil war by harry V. jaffa is the long awaited sequel to the author's 1959 book, Crisis of the House Divided. Although the specific objective of the A new birth of freedom is to examine lincoln's development of the Gettysburg Address, what makes the text so unique is that it focuses on lincoln as a scholar. This aspect of lincoln's personality is often overlooked in the context of autobiographical data on lincoln.With the realization that jaffa spends so much of he text focusing on lincoln as a scholar, this investigation seeks to provide a clear understanding of lincoln in this light. By examining what jaffa writes about lincoln as a scholar and comparing this to what others have written on this historical figure, it will be possible to demonstrate that jaffa's work makes a notable contribution to scholarly understanding of lincoln as both a man and a leader.