Can an ethical case ever be made for the use of torture during interrogation?
- The ''war on terror'' has exacerbated the belief that torture during interrogation is justifiable and has created a legal environment in which torture is possible
- The attempts to make an ethical case for the use of torture during interrogation
- The false assumption of the effectiveness of torture
- Torture as pragmatically desirable
- Torture as morally acceptable because of its pragmatic effectiveness
- However, torture can never be justifiable
- Torture is inherently and morally wrong
- Torture during interrogation is inefficient
- The problem of the slippery slope
In the ancient Greece and Rome, the testimony of a slave would not be taken into account in a judicial investigation, unless the statement had been obtained after the subject was submitted to torture. Nowadays, although torture has been banned from legal systems and condemned at the international level, it continues to be widespread. There has been a semantic evolution of the word "torture" through the centuries, and this evolution has also had an impact on the concept itself. In that sense, as Peters points out, before the 17th Century, the definition was purely legal, and referred to as a "torment inflicted by a public authority for ostensibly public purposes". After that date, the definition started to be more moral. It then evolved into becoming a sentimental one since the 19th Century. What this evolution means is that torture is perceived more and more as a private element, which, according to Peters, is inaccurate. As far as he is concerned, torture belongs to the public sphere, and as an illustration, he provides a comparison between torture and execution, explaining that torture is "aggravated assault", when execution means "murder?. This distinction is the one that has also been made by the legislators and that is transcribed in the texts prohibiting torture. This also separates it from other "cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment".
Cross-reference study on the notion of "Leadership"
«Biography: Joan of Arc. Introduction. Joan of Arc: A born leader. A charismatic leader. A lonely leader. Conclusion. Book review: Moments of truth, by Jan Carlzon. Introduction. Responding to change. Developing a vision. Managing subordinates. Applying a leadership style. Conclusion. Essay: Who am...»
«Joan of Arc's public career lasted only for two years but her history has come down through the ages, so that each year, her courage is praised on May 1st. Why is this sixteen-year-old girl engraved in our memory in such an unforgettable way? Answering to this question amounts to go over her...»
Does the viewing of slasher films empower female viewers?
«Introduction. The representation of women in films. The Texas Chain Saw Massacre film. Portwood-Stacer. Prom Night. The concept of revenge. Conclusion.»
«Throughout recent decades, the graphic violence of slasher films has become increasingly controversial. The horror slasher genre has become one of the most controversial film categories, receiving attention for the skillful and artful way these movies become emotion roller coasters (poised between...»
The working class before the First World War
«Introduction. First World War. The process of industrialization. Major innovations across Europe. La Vie tragique des tavailleurs. Conclusion.»
«The places the working class came from were often characterized by a high level of trade unions and a large amount of strikes. However, only a small part of workers used to be involved in working-class organisations at this time. People of the working-class are those who have no other way to...»