The Universal Declaration of Human Rights is primarily a Western document, limiting the claimed universal applicability of Human Rights
- How far did the great Western powers influence the writing of the UDHR.
- UDHR viewed as being Western.
- Cultural relativism.
On 10 December 1948, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) was adopted by the Third General Assembly of the United Nations. In the aftermath of WW2, nearly every state that had fought with the Western Allies wanted the atrocities of Nazism and Fascism to be prohibited. To do this solemnly, the concept of Human Rights hold by every human being seemed to be a good way of preventing such horror to happen again: it was condemning Nazism and Fascism as well as every other doctrine that would aim at the destruction of any population, individual, or culture. It was defending each person from aggression, torture and discrimination, only because of his or her being human, regardless of his/her nationality, religion, sex, and so on. At the time of writing, no one objected that it was a purely Western set of values, nor was it viewed as a kind of cultural imperialism. Criticisms emerged later. Today, the denying by some state of the existence of human rights occurs on a regular basis. Indeed, many states have tried to justify their practice by asserting that the right they apparently violate does not exist at all, with regards to their culture, customs or beliefs.
[...] Bibliography Susan Waltz, Universalizing HRs: the role of small states in the Construction of the UDHR, Human Rights Quaterly, 23/01/2001, 44-72 John Baylis and Steve Smith, The Globalization of World Politics, Oxford University Press http://www.ceu.hu/legal/ind_vs_state/Osiatynski_paper_2002.htm http://www.du.edu/gsis/hrhw/volumes/2001/1-2/morsink-eckert.pdf The Universal Declaration of Human Rights Wiktor Osiatynski (Central European University) explains these traditions in his speech the Universality of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights” that opened the 1Oth annual conference on “Individual vs. State”, Budapest, June 2002. Louis Henkin, Gerald L. Neuman, Diane F. [...]
[...] Indeed, their insistence on that point led to the final Article 2 which not only entitles everyone to rights and freedom [ ] without distinction of any kind, such as race, colour, sex language, religion, political pr other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth, or other status”, but also stipulates that distinction shall be made on the basis of the [ ] status of the country or territory to which a person belongs, whether it be independent, trust, non-self governing or under any other limitation of sovereignty.” It is made clear that the Declaration is Universal, and it is interesting noting that the largest extent of such a notion was achieved thanks to non- Western states, given that Western Empires could obviously not sincerely support such a threat to their imperialistic power. [...]
[...] However, though Western, some features were actually common to several theories: Mary Ann Glendon considers the second tradition as the one that guided the construction of the UDHR, and the reason of such a thinking is that the emphasis on community and duties were quite close to non-Western values (African and Asian culture) and common to many Western theories (Marxism and Christian thinking for instance). “Social progress and better standards of living” mentioned in the Preamble also illustrates the combination of different thoughts: Marxists, Christian, socialists and social-democrats stood for it. [...]
«Introduction. Meanings and methods of land reform in iran. Histories and theories of the land reform. Biography of a propagandist. Authenticating reform. The red specter. The black shadow. Landowners great and small. Oil and international prestige. Land reform as mo...»
«"My heart is with our village people, and as I think of their future I believe I see a magnificent vista lying ahead." Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, Mission For My Country (1960) In the twenty years leading up to Islamic Revolution, the landscape of Iran underwent significant change. This landscape-a...»
«Abstract.. Introduction.. Background.. Case company.. Research question.. Outlines of the research.. Literature review.. Recent trends in merger [e] acquisition activity.. Motives behind merger and acquisitions.. Why mergers and acquisitions fail?. Factors affecting successful mergers and...»
«Tata-Corus, Arcelor-Mittal, Daimler-Chrysler, America online- Time Warner.... The phenomenon of Merger and Acquisition has proved to be a very popular means for organizations to achieve growth and promote strategic change, especially during the last two decades. The reason that the concern within...»
«Introduction. About Ireland. Events. Conclusion.»
«For centuries, Ireland and Britain have had closely intertwined histories and relations. Ireland, as we know it today, has been influenced tremendously by its relations with Britain. It is known as a place of religious and cultural tension, much of which dates back to the eighteenth and nineteenth...»
«Introduction. Article 47 Protocol I Additional to the Geneva Conventions. The Gurkhas and the French Foreign Legion . The French Foreign Legion. The Gurkhas and the FFL: Mercenaries ?. To what extent the UN Convention on Mercenaries develops the law in this area. As to the definition of...»
«Critically analyse the prohibition against the use of mercenaries in Article 47 of API. - Would the Brigade of Gurkhas or the French Foreign Legion be considered as mercenaries under this definition ? - Evaluate the extent to which the UN Convention on Mercenaries develops the law in this...»